The Dogood Papers · Letters on Leadership

Senate Leadership Register

Starter Edition — Public Positions on the Next Senate Democratic Leader

Letters from the Republic · The Public Ledger
Last checked: November 16, 2026
Starter Edition 1 · Prepared for publication

Read Letter No. I · Inspect its evidence · Explore the series

A note from Silas

The Schumer-supporter column is, in my judgment, a list I would not want my senator on. My reasons belong in Letter No. I. Here, every name must be accompanied by a public record. A sharp opinion should survive a careful ledger.

What this register tells you

Senators choose their party leader. A contested Democratic leadership election uses a secret ballot. An endorsement reveals a public commitment; it does not reveal a future ballot. Incoming senators participate, while outgoing senators do not. Conference rules · ABC explanation, November 13

The present choice concerns leadership of the incoming Democratic majority. This starter edition records selected, checked positions. It is not a complete caucus census, a prediction, or a tally of votes already cast. An omitted name has not been assigned a position.

The candidates

Candidates appear separately from colleagues endorsing them.

Candidate and state Current role Public record Source
Chuck Schumer — New York Senator; incumbent Democratic leader November 12: Seeks to continue leading the caucus; points to its electoral success and says he has sufficient support. That last assertion is his claim. ABC, November 13
Chris Van Hollen — Maryland Senator; challenger November 12: Announced his candidacy, arguing that voters' demand for change requires new leadership. Official announcement

Publicly supports Schumer

These entries rest on an individual statement or attributable reporting of that statement. Dates are in 2026.

Member, state, and role Statement date Public record and stated reason Source
Angus King — Maine; current senator, independent November 12 Officially endorsed Schumer, citing electoral success, his proposed agenda, and Senate experience. King's official release
Brian Schatz — Hawaii; current senator November 12 Explicitly endorsed Schumer and pledged his caucus vote; credited the election victory and urged prompt unity. Schatz's official release
Jack Reed — Rhode Island; current senator November 12 Explicitly promised support, citing effectiveness and ability to lead a diverse caucus; welcomed a legitimate contest. Reed's official release
Kirsten Gillibrand — New York; current senator November 10 Told reporters she supports Schumer, crediting caucus coordination, fundraising, and campaign assistance. WLEA transcript, November 11
John Fetterman — Pennsylvania; current senator Publicly documented by November 11 Promised his vote for Schumer and credited candidate recruitment. The linked transcription reproduces recorded comments circulating November 10. RealClearPolitics transcript, November 11
Catherine Cortez Masto — Nevada; current senator November 12 Publicly promised support, citing Schumer's contribution to winning the majority. Post quoted by ABC, November 13
Jacky Rosen — Nevada; current senator November 12 Endorsed Schumer, citing electoral work and his experience leading the caucus. Post quoted by ABC, November 13

Publicly endorses Van Hollen

Member, state, and role Statement date Public record and stated reason Source
Bernie Sanders — Vermont; current senator, independent November 12 Endorsed Van Hollen, calling for a party that confronts concentrated power and serves working families. Public statement reported by ABC
Jeff Merkley — Oregon; current senator November 13 Gave Van Hollen his full support, citing his willingness to challenge powerful interests. Merkley's official release
Abdul El-Sayed — Michigan; senator-elect November 12 Explicitly endorsed Van Hollen, citing courage, experience, and priorities including health care and political reform. Released statement quoted by Roll Call
Peggy Flanagan — Minnesota; senator-elect November 13 Publicly endorsed Van Hollen as a leader capable of delivering the change her constituents demanded. The Hill report, via AOL

Explicitly opposes Schumer; replacement not declared

Opposing Schumer does not automatically constitute an endorsement of Van Hollen.

Member, state, and role Statement date Public record and stated reason Source
Elissa Slotkin — Michigan; current senator November 13 Explicitly said she would not vote for Schumer. Reported productive conversations with Van Hollen but did not endorse him. Denver remarks reported by Colorado Politics
Juliana Stratton — Illinois; senator-elect November 10 Reaffirmed her no-Schumer promise, seeking new leadership responsive to communities; said she would hear candidates' visions before choosing. WMBD report, via AOL
Adam Hamilton — Kansas; senator-elect November 8 reaffirmation Reaffirmed opposition on Meet the Press, seeking less polarizing leadership that could bring people together. Washington Examiner report

No candidate commitment verified

This category records an evidence limit. It does not assign a hidden preference.

Member, state, and role Evidence date Why no endorsement is assigned Source
Jon Ossoff — Georgia; current senator Report updated November 15, Pacific time His spokesperson said he had not backed a candidate, despite an unnamed Schumer ally including him in a predicted-support list. The Hill, via AOL
Maggie Hassan — New Hampshire; current senator Report updated November 15, Pacific time An unnamed ally predicted support. This review located no individual commitment sufficient to classify her as endorsing either candidate. The Hill, via AOL
Chris Pappas — New Hampshire; senator-elect November 4 report; rechecked November 16 Called for new voices, but the reported remarks did not establish an explicit no-Schumer pledge or a named endorsement. Roll Call

Other endorsements: outside the voting register

Tina Smith — Minnesota, retiring senator: Endorsed Van Hollen November 13; she cannot vote in this leadership election. Washington Post

How to read and update this record

  • Prefer primary evidence. Official releases are identified; reporting that reproduces a statement is labeled accordingly.
  • Keep dates honest. A publication date is not necessarily the statement date. Gillibrand's recorded commitment predates Van Hollen's formal candidacy; no later reversal was verified.
  • Require an attributable commitment. An anonymous prediction, fundraising relationship, policy vote, or praise for someone's work does not by itself establish a leadership endorsement.
  • Preserve changes. A future update should retain the earlier position, add the new statement and date, and explain the reclassification. A named endorsement supersedes a generic demand for change.
  • Keep the March 2025 record separate. The “Feckless Ten” label concerns the funding-cloture episode discussed in the Public Ledger. That roll call cannot establish a senator's November 2026 leadership preference.

Reader question: What has your senator publicly committed to, what reasons have they given, and what results will they demand from the person they support?

Update history

Date Edition Change
November 16, 2026 Starter Edition 1 Initial prepared register with selected verified positions, unresolved examples, and a separate nonvoter note.

Back to Letter No. I · Public Ledger · Series guide

The Republic Replies

Questions, disagreements, and inconvenient facts are welcome.

Write to the Editor with corrections or submissions.