The Dogood Papers · Letter
Letter No. 0 — A Letter from Silas to Mrs. Silence Dogood
Silas B. Dogood introduces himself and his new undertaking in a letter to Mrs. Silence Dogood.
To the Esteemed Mrs. Silence Dogood,
My Dear Madam,
I trust this letter finds you well, wherever fictional widows of considerable intelligence and questionable obedience to authority spend their eternities.
I write from the year 2026, some three centuries after your first appearance in the New-England Courant, to inform you that the Republic remains a work in progress.
I regret to report that progress has been somewhat uneven.
We have conquered the skies, walked upon the moon, placed the collected knowledge of mankind into devices small enough to fit in one's pocket, and developed machines capable of answering nearly any question.
We have not, however, developed a reliable means of persuading elected officials to answer the question actually asked.
I suspect you would find this familiar.
You will be pleased to learn that the printing press has undergone remarkable improvements. We no longer require ink, paper, or a muscular apprentice to arrange tiny metal letters backward.
Instead, we employ invisible particles, illuminated glass, and an assortment of electronic contraptions that occasionally refuse to cooperate for reasons no reasonable person can comprehend.
The result is that anyone may now publish an opinion instantly, anywhere in the world.
This has proven both a triumph of liberty and a considerable misfortune for civilization.
Indeed, the principal difficulty of modern discourse is no longer that ordinary citizens cannot make themselves heard. It is that everyone is speaking simultaneously, frequently without the inconvenience of first having thought.
I confess that I, too, have opinions.
Quite a few, in fact.
Some are carefully considered. Others arrive unexpectedly while watching the evening news and require several cups of coffee before they can safely be committed to print.
Or whatever we call print these days.
On the Matter of Your Literary Descendant
You may wonder why I have presumed to adopt your distinguished surname.
I assure you it was not done lightly.
I had hoped to invent something entirely new. Unfortunately, Franklin appears to have gotten here three hundred years ahead of me.
The inconsiderate fellow.
And so I have taken the name Silas B. Dogood, in the hope that some small measure of your wit, independence, and willingness to disturb the comfortable might survive in these modern letters.
As for the middle initial, I prefer to leave its meaning unsettled.
A gentleman must retain some mystery, particularly when he possesses so little else.
On the State of the Republic
You might reasonably expect that two and a half centuries of independence would have cured us of certain political afflictions.
Alas.
We continue to suffer from politicians who mistake public office for personal property, parties that occasionally confuse loyalty with obedience, and institutions that appear to believe accountability is something best practiced by others.
We have developed elaborate procedures for selecting our leaders, complicated rules for conducting public business, and entire professions devoted to explaining why nothing can be done.
Yet we continue to hear that the next election will change everything.
Sometimes it does.
Sometimes it merely changes the names on the stationery.
I do not mean to suggest that our Republic has accomplished nothing. Far from it. We have expanded rights, corrected historic injustices, and achieved advances that would have astonished even your imaginative young creator.
But the work remains unfinished.
The Founders spoke of forming a more perfect Union, not a perfect one. They wisely left room for improvement.
Rather generous of them, considering how much room we have continued to require.
On My Unusual Assistant
There is another development I feel obliged to disclose.
I have acquired an assistant.
Not an apprentice, exactly. Nor a secretary. Nor, so far as I can determine, a person.
It is called Artificial Intelligence, although I generally refer to it as my AI BFF.
It helps me gather information, organize thoughts, untangle troublesome sentences, and occasionally rescue a perfectly respectable paragraph from my determined efforts to make it incomprehensible.
This is particularly helpful when my brain and my intentions find themselves traveling at different speeds.
The arrangement is not without difficulty.
My assistant is unfailingly patient, distressingly well-informed on certain subjects, and occasionally possessed of the confidence of a senator explaining a bill he has not read.
I therefore insist upon checking its work.
It seems only fair. I have spent much of my life questioning human authority; it would be inconsistent to surrender my judgment to an arrangement of silicon and mathematics.
The thoughts remain mine.
The occasional semicolon is negotiable.
On the Necessity of Laughter
I have also discovered that paying close attention to the affairs of government can be hazardous to one's disposition.
There are days when the news makes one wonder whether the entire political establishment has mistaken a constitutional republic for a traveling theatrical production.
And yet I remain hopeful.
Perhaps foolishly.
But I believe that cynicism is too easy an answer to the difficulties of self-government.
A citizen who has surrendered all hope has little reason to participate. A citizen who can still laugh, question, learn, and occasionally make a nuisance of himself remains capable of doing some good.
Humor, I suspect, is not the opposite of seriousness.
It is sometimes what allows serious people to continue.
So I intend to laugh when laughter is warranted, object when objection is necessary, and consult the public record before accusing anyone of conduct that the evidence cannot support.
I shall take the Republic seriously.
Myself, somewhat less so.
On My New Undertaking
I have therefore resolved to issue a series of letters under the title:
Letters from the Republic
They shall be put into circulation by a Citizen Activist, whenever the Republic requires attention.
Within these pages, I shall offer The Dogood Papers, examining the words and deeds of those entrusted with public power.
There shall also be a Public Ledger, where evidence may be inspected without requiring readers to accept my conclusions merely because I have expressed them with confidence.
Other citizens may contribute their correspondence, and the public shall have an opportunity to reply.
This last arrangement may prove hazardous.
But I believe the Republic has survived worse than an honest disagreement.
And lest anyone imagine that citizenship is an occupation reserved for elected officials, wealthy benefactors, or those who enjoy attending meetings, I intend to repeat a simple proposition:
You CAN do something!
You can ask a question.
You can examine a vote.
You can challenge an explanation.
You can write a letter.
You can organize with your neighbors.
You can refuse to mistake resignation for wisdom.
And occasionally, you can laugh at the absurdity of it all.
A Final, Modest Request
I must conclude, dear Madam, for the hour grows late and my coffee has grown cold.
Should you encounter young Benjamin Franklin in whatever literary eternity you inhabit, please convey my admiration.
And perhaps remind him that some of us would have appreciated his leaving a few original ideas for subsequent generations.
As for me, I have work to do.
The Republic is still here.
Its citizens are still arguing.
Its leaders are still explaining.
And the pursuit of a more perfect Union continues, notwithstanding the occasional shortage of common sense.
I remain,
Your affectionate and somewhat exasperated literary descendant,
Silas B. Dogood
Citizen, correspondent, and reluctant observer of public affairs.
Occasionally known to his creditors as Silas B. Needy.
Silas Says…
A more perfect Union was never going to be a perfect picnic. But surely someone could have remembered the coffee.
☕
The Republic Replies
Questions, disagreements, and inconvenient facts are welcome.
Write to the Editor with corrections or submissions.